Oscars
An examination of this year's Best Picture nominees and their relationship to mental health
For the last two years, my friend Anne and I have traded Academy Awards party-hosting duties. At my house, we watched as Will Smith lost his cool on live TV. At her house, we enjoyed seeing “Everything, Everywhere, All at Once” do so well. Next Sunday is the 2024 version of the ceremony, so I thought this would be a perfect opportunity to talk about the mental health themes found in all of the films nominated for Best Picture.
These ten movies weave a complex narrative that transcends the boundaries of entertainment, delving deep into the intricate web of mental health. Each film, distinct in its genre and storytelling, serves as a prism through which we can explore and discuss vital mental health themes. These narratives offer a profound commentary on the human condition, from identity and self-perception to resilience and the echoes of historical trauma.
"Barbie" might seem like a light-hearted journey through a world of whimsy and color. Still, it cleverly uses its iconic protagonist to address issues of body image, self-esteem, and the relentless pursuit of perfection. The film invites us to question the societal molds that shape our self-view and mental health, urging a conversation on self-acceptance and liberation from stifling stereotypes.
"Oppenheimer" takes us into the tumultuous mind of J. Robert Oppenheimer, exploring the immense psychological burden borne by those at the forefront of monumental yet morally ambiguous scientific achievements. It's a narrative steeped in ethical dilemmas, highlighting the profound mental toll of historical significance and moral responsibility.
"Killers of the Flower Moon" brings to light the tragic Osage murders, weaving a narrative that reflects on the mental scars inflicted by greed, exploitation, and racial injustice. It's a poignant exploration of the psychological aftermath of violence and betrayal, emphasizing the need for acknowledging and healing historical traumas to foster communal and individual well-being.
"The Holdovers" provides a touching reflection on human connections, mentorship, and the power of empathy within the microcosm of a New England prep school. It addresses the mental health implications of isolation and the transformative impact of understanding and compassion, underscoring the importance of supportive relationships in navigating life's challenges.
"Poor Things" reimagines the Frankenstein myth, offering a narrative that champions autonomy, identity, and the defiance of societal constraints. Bella Baxter's journey is a compelling narrative on self-discovery and liberation, prompting discussions on the mental health implications of societal pressures and the quest for self-acceptance.
"Maestro" delves into the life of Leonard Bernstein, portraying the intricate dance between creative genius and the burdens of expectation. It explores the mental health challenges faced by those in the public eye, highlighting the delicate balance between artistic brilliance and emotional well-being.
"Anatomy of a Fall" presents a riveting tale that navigates the murky waters of truth, perception, and justice, unraveling the psychological impacts of grief and the relentless pursuit of closure. It's a narrative that examines the consuming nature of seeking justice and its effects on mental health.
"The Zone of Interest" is a gripping and profound narrative set against the harrowing backdrop of a Nazi concentration camp. Through the lens of several characters, the film explores the chilling banality of evil and the complex interplay of power, complicity, and moral ambiguity that defines life within and around the camp. With masterful storytelling, the book-turned-movie delves into the psyche of its characters, revealing the unsettling ease with which ordinary people can become enmeshed in atrocities. It challenges viewers to confront uncomfortable truths about human nature and the capacity for cruelty, all while weaving a tale of love, despair, and the quest for redemption in the darkest of times. "The Zone of Interest" is a haunting reminder of history's horrors and a poignant exploration of the human heart's contradictions.
"Past Lives" is a mesmerizing exploration of love, destiny, and the intricate tapestries of life that transcend time and space. This poignant narrative unfolds through the lives of characters who are inexplicably drawn together, suggesting a profound connection that defies the bounds of a single lifetime. As their stories interweave, the movie delves into themes of reincarnation, the enduring power of love, and the mysterious forces that guide our journeys. With each turn of the page, "Past Lives" invites readers to ponder the possibility of previous existences and the impact of past experiences on our present selves. It's a compelling tale that not only entertains but also offers a unique lens through which to view the connections between us, urging a contemplation of the soul's journey through time.
Lastly, "American Fiction" critiques the literary world through the lens of authenticity and racial identity, probing the mental health challenges of navigating societal expectations and the quest for genuine self-expression. It raises critical questions about the impact of tokenism and the search for authenticity in a world governed by labels and expectations.
Together, these films form a mosaic of narratives that entertain and provoke thought and dialogue on mental health, reminding us of the power of cinema to reflect, challenge, and inspire our understanding of the human psyche.
While this year, I’ve got other plans I can’t wait to see who wins the awards. I have my favorites, despite not having seen all the films yet, but you’ll have to listen to Happy Monday to hear who we think should and will win these coveted trophies.
This content is for educational and entertainment purposes and is not the same as therapy. If you need to talk to someone, go to PsychologyToday.com or one of the many online therapy platforms available and start treatment with a professional today!
For access to the weekly writing prompts, daily affirmations, and other exclusive content, consider becoming a paid subscriber!
Don’t forget to listen to “Happy Monday” every week wherever you get your podcasts! Go to happymondaypodcast.net more and follow us on Instagram @happymonday.podcast.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Kirk Sheppard to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.